This information should be considered together with what P.R. [long time clinician, specializing in ASD and A:s doctor] testified about A:s established and documented difficulties, which includes an extreme reluctancy to engage in any physical contact with anybody, and she shys away when anyone in the surroundings tries to make physical contact with her, like a friendly pat on the shoulder. Even though A had consumed alcohol, which she most likely is not familiar with, it appears unreasonably unlikely that her disorders and reluctancy towards physical contact should make such a profound change in her behaviour that she should engage in the behaviour described by J.P. [the accused] and especially with a total stranger.Considering these statements from P.R., the story of J.P. is regarded as obviously truthless.

Regarding the just mentioned statements, Tingsrätten trusts the description of the events from A and concludes that it is without doubts established that J.P. forced A into this chain of events with violence and threats of more violence. Tingsrätten goes with the prosecutor and this deed is to be regarded as rape.

In conclusion, Hovrätten is aware that there are strong reasons to believe that A against her will has been subject to sexual abuse.

On the other hand she has some hesitations in her statements, adding the fact that her expressions might have been hard to interpret for J.P. and there is also no independent proof that gives A:s story enough support. This makes it impossible to judge without doubts that J.P. conciously forced intercourse upon her in the way the prosecutor claims.

The indictment is therefore to be dismissed.

weasley skrev:conciously

Savanten Svante skrev:Tack, ni som skriver och översätter på WP.

weasley skrev:

Savanten Svante skrev:Tack, ni som skriver och översätter på WP.

Klistra in det jag har översatt vettja. Jag har inget konto och ids inte skaffa ett heller. HGJ hittade ett stavfel så den som klipper och klistrar kan ju korrigera det, det vore snällt.

weasley skrev:

Savanten Svante skrev:Tack, ni som skriver och översätter på WP.

Klistra in det jag har översatt vettja. Jag har inget konto och ids inte skaffa ett heller. HGJ hittade ett stavfel så den som klipper och klistrar kan ju korrigera det, det vore snällt.

weasley skrev:

This information should be considered together with what P.R. [long time clinician, specializing in ASD and A:s doctor] testified about A:s established and documented difficulties, which includes an extreme reluctancy to engage in any physical contact with anybody, and she shys away when anyone in the surroundings tries to make physical contact with her, like a friendly pat on the shoulder. Even though A had consumed alcohol, which she most likely is not familiar with, it appears unreasonably unlikely that her disorders and reluctancy towards physical contact should make such a profound change in her behaviour that she should engage in the behaviour described by J.P. [the accused] and especially with a total stranger.Considering these statements from P.R., the story of J.P. is regarded as obviously truthless.

Regarding the just mentioned statements, Tingsrätten trusts the description of the events from A and concludes that it is without doubts established that J.P. forced A into this chain of events with violence and threats of more violence. Tingsrätten goes with the prosecutor and this deed is to be regarded as rape.

vadloink skrev:innebär väl att om en väldtäktsman lindar silvertejp runt offrets mun så han eller hon inte kan protestera så är det oklart om det är en våldtäkt?

Le_inimitable skrev:Har ni tänkt på att motiveringen kan användas åt andra hållet också?

Zima33 skrev:Jag läste nånstans att i många (alla?) EU-länder har man infört krav på samtycke. Sverige har inte det, därför kan en person som är förlamad av skräck och inte kan/vågar säga nej inte bli våldtagen i Sverige.

Parvlon skrev:Vart har du läst detta? Kanske du "kom på det" efter att du sett denna trådens fantastiska rubrik?